How should I defrost frozen seafood?

If it’s vacuum-packed, remove it from the packaging and thaw in the fridge for 12–24 hours. Use within five days. In a pinch, remove from packaging, seal in a bag, and submerge in very cold water until thawed. Always pat seafood dry after defrosting.

Should I brine my fish before cooking?

Brining can improve flavor and texture. Quick 6% brine: dissolve 5 Tbsp kosher/coarse salt in 2 quarts cold water; soak up to 12 minutes, then pat dry. Slow 4.7% brine: 2 Tbsp salt + 3 Tbsp white sugar in 1 quart cold water; soak 5–12 hours, rinse, and dry. Dry brine (cure): rub 1 Tbsp salt + 1/2 tsp sugar on the fillet; rest 10 minutes, then rinse and pat dry.

We might be! Every team member earns a living wage, receives a health care subsidy, and has access to a 401(k) with a 4% employer match. View open roles on Culinary Agents, or send your resume and a short note about why you want to join the crew.

Coming soon—we’re cooking, testing, and tweaking to make sure every recipe is worth your fish.

Should I be suspicious of farm-raised fish?

Not at all—quality depends on how seafood is raised or harvested. We partner with state-of-the-art mariculture operations that prioritize clean, responsible practices, monitor water quality and feed, and minimize environmental impact. Farm-raised fish can be fresher, consistent, parasite-free, and as flavorful as wild. We work with open-water pen systems and advanced closed/recirculating aquaculture systems, which reduce pressure on wild populations and support decarbonization. We offer both wild and farmed options and are always transparent about sourcing.

What does "ikejime" mean?

Ikejime is a traditional Japanese method that quickly and humanely ends brain and spinal activity, minimizing stress and lactic acid. The result is cleaner flavor, better texture, and longer-lasting freshness. The Fish Guy is proud to carry one of Chicagoland’s widest selections of ikejime-prepared fish.

Our Catch

Case Menus & Market

Fish moves fast around here — best to call and make sure it’s still swimming.

Finfish

Digital illustration of a person dressed as Santa Claus sitting beside a large lobster, with a Christmas-themed backdrop featuring a window with a fish hook and fishing line.

Featured

August 22nd

Illustration of a man with a beard sleeping on a boat, surrounded by fish, with the text 'The Fish Guy' above.

A line drawing of a person lying in bed with arms behind head, wearing glasses and socks. There are three fish swimming above and around the person.

Need to place a special
order? Just ask.

Order Now

Lobster roll on a toasted bun with chopped herbs, potato chips, and a small bowl of coleslaw on a teal plate.

EATS TO-GO

SANDWICHES MADE-TO-ORDER

All sandwiches are made to order and served with house slaw and your choice of Great Lakes Potato Chips.

See Full Menu

"WE GO THE DISTANCE FOR GREAT"

We’ve been the quiet hookup for Chicago’s top chefs and hospitality pros for nearly 30 years. If you can dream it, we can source it. Get in touch and let’s talk.

Wholesale